scottm
Member
I'm not saying the original Star Wars films are sh*t (they're probably my 2nd favourite films after LOTR), but LOTR raises the notch even higher. But to possibly compare LOTR with eps 1 & 2 is shameful. And as for ep 3 having no "real" external location shots (yes they're all cgi :-( ) why oh why.
I think Lucas has lost the plot and people are just too scared to say "No George, that doesn't work".
I hope I'm wrong and that ep 3 is great - but I'm not convinced. It's not just me though, most people I talk to hate ep 1 & 2. I don't hate them (I own them both on DVD) I just don't think they do justice to a great franchise. Hope they don't muck up Indie 4 (subtitled - and the lost zimmer frame ) either
I think Lucas has lost the plot and people are just too scared to say "No George, that doesn't work".
I hope I'm wrong and that ep 3 is great - but I'm not convinced. It's not just me though, most people I talk to hate ep 1 & 2. I don't hate them (I own them both on DVD) I just don't think they do justice to a great franchise. Hope they don't muck up Indie 4 (subtitled - and the lost zimmer frame ) either